Lavoie described the January 2020 helicopter accident as “devastating and life-shattering” before he condemned the conduct of the sheriff and fire department defendants, “who were supposed to protect the dignity of those who perished on that hillside.” More than once during his closing statements, Lavoie said the behavior “shocks the conscience.”
Vanessa is “haunted by the idea that the images could come out” and is unable to “calm down” from the anxiety, said Lavoie. “She feels asphyxiated,” he stated, before asking the jury, “How much can a person bear?” There is a “chance the photos could someday surface,” according to Lavoie, who asked what the percentage of that occurring is, before he concluded, “Whatever each of us thinks that number is, it’s definitely not zero.”